Legal landscape note: This article was originally published in 2014 and describes the law as it stood at that time. New Jersey law changes frequently -- contact us to discuss how the current law applies to your situation.
In State v. Peralta, a published 2014 decision, a three-judge Appellate Division panel held that a police officer's failure to read a suspected drunk driver the statutory warning about the consequences of refusing a breath test does not invalidate a DWI conviction when the driver voluntarily submits to the test. "An officer's failure to read the statutory statement is irrelevant when the accused submits to the test," Judge Clarkson Fisher Jr. wrote for the panel.
The ruling rejected the reasoning of a 2010 unpublished decision, State v. Tirado, which defense lawyers had used to argue that a conviction should be thrown out if the State could not prove the standard statement was read -- even where the driver consented. Peralta closed off that line of defense for consent cases, while confirming that the reading of the statutory statement remains critical in a prosecution for refusal.
The defendant in the case had been arrested on suspicion of drunk driving, took a breath test showing a blood-alcohol content of .19 percent, and was convicted in municipal court. On appeal, the panel assumed for the sake of argument that the statement had not been read to him and affirmed anyway, because he had freely consented to give the sample.
The distinction matters: if you are charged with refusal, whether and how the standard statement was read to you can be central to the case. If you submitted to the test, the fight shifts to other issues -- the stop, the operator's qualifications, and the reliability of the result. An experienced DWI attorney can evaluate which defenses actually apply to your facts.
Based on reporting by Michael Booth, "Appeals Court Reverses Course on Breath-Test Warnings," New Jersey Law Journal, October 31, 2014.
To request a consultation, call (800) 709-1131 or use the contact form. The intake team will review the request before any consultation is confirmed.