Simon Law Group

Call Today 800-709-1131

Located at 40 West High Street Somerville, NJ 08876


  • Home
  • Services
    • Criminal Defense
    • Civil Litigation
    • Divorce & Custody Issues
    • Domestic Violence
    • Injuries & Wrongful Death
    • NJ DUI/DWI & DUID
    • Real Estate
    • Bankruptcy & Foreclosure
    • Wills & Estate Planning
  • About Us
    • Attorneys
    • Testimonials
    • Privacy Policy
  • Blog
  • Contact Us

Court Relaxes Affidavit of Merit Rule in Malpractice Cases

Posted by Britt Simon on Feb 4 2015

  • Tweet
The requirements for an affidavit of merit when bringing a malpractice case appears to have been reduced. The Appellate Division as indicated its claims fall outside the professional defendants specific expertise than the affidavit could be unnecessary. This would appear to be common sense as a defendant who has no expertise in a specific area could not be expected to any acceptable standard level of performance in an area which he has no professional expertise and is not represented having any.  In the case of Hill International v. Atlantic City Board of Education, this matter originates as a construction case. The real question here is will this new ruling applied in other fields such as medical and legal malpractice cases. Stay tuned.
Should you need help with a NJ civil lawsuit, NJ Malpractice case or another type of case, call today to speak with a NJ Lawyer to help you. 800-709-1131
Speak with an Attorney

Court Relaxes Affidavit of Merit Rule in Malpractice Cases

 

Michael Booth, New Jersey Law Journal

December 30, 2014  

A New Jersey appeals court has given plaintiffs in professional malpractice cases some leeway in the standards needed for obtaining an affidavit of merit.

In a published opinion, a three-judge Appellate Division panel on Dec. 30 said an affidavit of merit from a “like-licensed” professional might not be required if the claims fall outside of the defendant’s area of professional expertise.

“Minor variations in the scope or terms of the respective licenses held by the affiant that do not bear upon material issues in the case will not disqualify the affiant, so long as both professionals are licensed within the same category of professionals,” wrote Appellate Division Judge Jack Sabatino in Hill International v. Atlantic City Board of Education.

Judges George Leone and Marie Simonelli joined in the ruling.

At issue is whether a plaintiff in a school construction case can submit an affidavit of merit from an engineer against a defendant architect since some areas of their practice areas overlap.

Sabatino said New Jersey’s 1995 Affidavit of Merit Statute, enacted in order to weed out nonmeritorious professional malpractice lawsuits in the early stages of litigation, clearly requires that an affidavit of merit be filed by a “like-licensed” person in the same profession and area of expertise.

That rule can be relaxed, however, when the claims do not involve the defendant’s duties as a professional, Sabatino said.

In this multiparty case, a plaintiff, Cobra Construction Co., of North Arlington, N.J., is pursuing claims against defendant SOSH Architects of Atlantic City, N.J., alleging, among other things, lack of coordination and planning, delays in obtaining permits and approvals and making timely payments.

Sabatino said not all of the claims allege breaches of professional duty.

“Hence, if a licensed professional deliberately hurts a client or patient in an office fist fight, or purposefully spreads falsehoods on the Internet about a former client who refuses to pay the professional’s bill, an AOM will not be required to support the claims against that professional for the intentional torts of assault and battery or defamation,” Sabatino said. “Such intentional wrongdoing is outside the sphere of professional malpractice litigation that the AOM statute is designed to regulate.”

The Atlantic City Board of Education retained SOSH Architects to design a new elementary school on Richmond Avenue in 2008, according to the appeals court’s opinion. Cobra Construction eventually was hired as the general contractor, and the school’s construction was to be substantially completed by August 2011.

Various problems arose during the course of construction, leading to litigation among several parties, including that between Cobra Construction and SOSH, the opinion said. In accordance with the statute, Cobra Construction obtained an affidavit of merit attesting to the alleged professional malpractice of SOSH and one of its architects, Peter Gallagher. However, the affidavit of merit was prepared by a licensed engineer, James Beach, and not an architect.

SOSH moved to have the complaint dismissed on the grounds that Cobra Construction had failed to obtain an affidavit of merit within the required time frame. A trial judge, however, ruled that the claim could stand because the engineer and the architect’s specialties overlapped to such a point that Beach could be considered qualified to opine on an architect’s professional competence.

SOSH appealed the judge’s ruling.

The appeals court emphasized that prior case law mandates that claims involving professional malpractice must be accompanied by an affidavit prepared by a licensed professional engaged in the same profession.

Although job functions may overlap between licensed professionals, that does not mean a person licensed in one profession may issue a statement attesting to the malpractice of a person in another profession, Sabatino said.

For example, he said a nurse could not be an affiant against a doctor in a blood-pressure case even though both are trained in how to take blood pressure readings. Nor could an accountant in a tax case involving a defendant attorney prepare an affidavit of merit even though both are trained to prepare tax returns, Sabatino said.

“Construing the AOM statute to require such like-licensed affiants is consistent with the norms of fairness as well as a recognition of the reasonable expectations of a licensed professional,” Sabatino said.

But not every claim against a licensed professional alleges professional malpractice or a deviation from the professional standard of care, Sabatino said.

“An affidavit from such a like-licensed expert is not, however, required when the plaintiff’s claims are confined to theories of vicarious liability or agency and do not assert or implicate deviations from the defendant’s professional standards of care,” he said.

Topics: Civil Lawsuit

Subscribe to Email Updates

Recent Posts

Posts by Topic

  • NJ Lawyers (59)
  • NJ Lawyer (57)
  • Lawyer (49)
  • Lawyer Group (49)
  • Simon Attorneys (48)
  • Simon Law Group (48)
  • NJ Attorney (45)
  • nj court (38)
  • nj court system (38)
  • NJ Criminal Lawyer (31)
  • Criminal (29)
  • DUI (28)
  • NJ DUI Attorney (28)
  • DUI/DWI- Underage Drinking (22)
  • Family Law (21)
  • DWI (20)
  • DWI, DUI, DUI/DWI- Underage Drinking (19)
  • Drunk Driving (19)
  • NJ DUI (19)
  • Workers Compensation (19)
  • nj divorce attorney (19)
  • nj family law (19)
  • Divorce (18)
  • Family Law Attorney (18)
  • NJ DWI (18)
  • Personal Injury (18)
  • NJ Criminal Attorney (17)
  • NJ Divorce (16)
  • NJ Family Lawyer (16)
  • criminal attorneys (16)
  • Family Lawyer (15)
  • nj criminal defense (15)
  • Custody (14)
  • Municipal Court (14)
  • Child Support (13)
  • DUI Defense (13)
  • DWI Defense (13)
  • Employment Law (12)
  • Estate Planning (12)
  • Estate Planning Attorney (12)
  • NJ Possession Attorney (12)
  • criminal defense (12)
  • nj traffic attorney (12)
  • Field Sobriety Tests (11)
  • courts (11)
  • Accident (10)
  • Child Custody (10)
  • Child Custody Agreement (10)
  • Criminal Record (10)
  • Traffic Violations (10)
  • child relocation (10)
  • Civil Lawsuit (9)
  • Marijuana (9)
  • Possession (9)
  • Domestic Violence (8)
  • Drugs (8)
  • Estates (8)
  • Lawsuit (8)
  • Medical Marijuana Law (8)
  • Abuse (7)
  • Alimony (7)
  • Discrimination (7)
  • Marijuana Possession (7)
  • Parenting (7)
  • Possession Charge (7)
  • Sexual Assault (7)
  • Traffic Attorney (7)
  • dui checkpoints (7)
  • dwi checkpoints (7)
  • sobriety checkpoint (7)
  • under the influence (7)
  • Child Endangerment (6)
  • DYFS (6)
  • NJ Addiction (6)
  • NJ Bankruptcy (6)
  • Planning for the Future (6)
  • Traffic Stop (6)
  • Wills (6)
  • living trust (6)
  • prenuptial (6)
  • trust (6)
  • trusts (6)
  • Asset Management (5)
  • Bankruptcy (5)
  • Child Abuse (5)
  • Drug Test (5)
  • Employment Lawyer (5)
  • Future Plans (5)
  • Intent to Distribute (5)
  • Intent to Sell (5)
  • National Highway Traffic Safety Administration (5)
  • Schedule 1 (5)
  • Schedule I (5)
  • Superior Court (5)
  • Traffic (5)
  • bankruptcy attorneys (5)
  • estate (5)
  • nj traffic (5)
  • pendente lite (5)
  • pendente lite relief (5)
  • prenuptial agreement (5)
  • property (5)
  • Benefits (4)
  • Distribution of Wealth (4)
  • Drug Court (4)
  • Final Restraining Order (4)
  • Foreclosure (4)
  • Immigration Lawyer (4)
  • Injured (4)
  • Litigation (4)
  • Medical Malpractice (4)
  • NJ Foreclosure Lawyer (4)
  • Real Estate (4)
  • Schedule Classification (4)
  • Temporary Restraining Order (4)
  • Traffic Accident (4)
  • TrafficStop (4)
  • dcpp (4)
  • equitable distribution (4)
  • will planning (4)
  • Chapter 13 (3)
  • Chapter 7 (3)
  • Child Neglect (3)
  • Disability (3)
  • Elder Law (3)
  • FRO (3)
  • Foreclosure Defense (3)
  • Imigration Attorney (3)
  • Indictable (3)
  • Malpractice (3)
  • Medical Expenses (3)
  • Moving Violations (3)
  • NJ Estate Planning (3)
  • NJ Foreclosure (3)
  • NJ Foreclosure Attorney (3)
  • NJ Immigration (3)
  • NJ Malpractice Lawyer (3)
  • NJ Opioid Addiction (3)
  • Neglect (3)
  • Police (3)
  • Prison (3)
  • Social Security Disability (3)
  • TRO (3)
  • Tax Assessment (3)
  • expungement (3)
  • nj workers comp (3)
  • nj workers compensation (3)
  • power of attorney (3)
  • Adult Child (2)
  • Appeals (2)
  • Bankruptcy Scammers (2)
  • Business Law (2)
  • Chapter 11 (2)
  • Chapter 12 (2)
  • Child Neglet (2)
  • Corporate Law (2)
  • Defamation (2)
  • Divorce Lawyer (2)
  • Estate Attorney (2)
  • FST (2)
  • Fraud (2)
  • Immigration (2)
  • Juvenile (2)
  • Lemon (2)
  • Lemon Car (2)
  • Lemon Law (2)
  • Lemon Law Lawyer (2)
  • Liability (2)
  • Malpractice Lawyer (2)
  • Mandatory Minimum (2)
  • Mediation (2)
  • Murder (2)
  • NJ Alimony (2)
  • NJ Malpractice (2)
  • NJ Medical Malpractice (2)
  • Official Misconduct (2)
  • Opioid (2)
  • Opioid Addiction (2)
  • Punitive Damages (2)
  • Restraining Order (2)
  • SFST (2)
  • SSDI (2)
  • Social Security Insurance (2)
  • Warrants (2)
  • Wrongful Termination (2)
  • emancipated (2)
  • living will (2)
  • nj property tax (2)
  • nj tax appeal (2)
  • property tax (2)
  • tax attorney (2)
  • Alert System (1)
  • Burglary (1)
  • Civil Reservation (1)
  • Class Action (1)
  • Compassionate Use Act (1)
  • Consumer Fraud Act (1)
  • Consumer Protection (1)
  • Cybersecurity (1)
  • Debt (1)
  • Debt Collection (1)
  • Deportation (1)
  • Dodd (1)
  • Dodd Hearing (1)
  • Dodd Removal (1)
  • Drones (1)
  • Ethics (1)
  • Expungement Lawyer (1)
  • Expungement Lawyer Nj (1)
  • Expungement NJ (1)
  • Guardianship (1)
  • ICE (1)
  • Illegal immigration (1)
  • Insurance (1)
  • Invasion of Privacy (1)
  • Judicial Foreclosure (1)
  • Kingpin Statute (1)
  • Legal Custody (1)
  • Legislation (1)
  • Miranda Rights (1)
  • Murder Conviction (1)
  • NHTSA (1)
  • OPRA (1)
  • Oxycontin (1)
  • Physical custody (1)
  • Post Traumatic Stress Disorder (1)
  • Probable Cause (1)
  • Products Liability (1)
  • Refusal (1)
  • Residential Custody (1)
  • SSI (1)
  • Search and Seizure (1)
  • Sex Offenders (1)
  • Supreme Court (1)
  • Tax Appeals (1)
  • Tort Law (1)
  • Trafficking (1)
  • Triparenting (1)
  • Vehichle Searches (1)
  • Weapons (1)
  • Wrongful Death (1)
  • consentual sex (1)
  • dashcam (1)
  • foreign national (1)
  • foreign nationals (1)
  • fresh start (1)
  • illegal search and seizure (1)
  • manslaughter (1)
  • mortgage (1)
  • nj property tax assessment (1)
  • parole (1)
  • parole hearing (1)
  • parole violation (1)
  • possession of a handgun (1)
  • probation (1)
  • probation hearing (1)
  • probation violation (1)
  • property tax appeal (1)
  • property tax appeal attorney (1)
  • property tax appeal lawyer (1)
  • same sex parenting (1)
  • sentencing (1)
  • shoplift (1)
  • shoplifting (1)
  • special needs (1)
  • special needs trust (1)
  • tax lawyer (1)
  • vehicular manslaughter (1)
  • warrantless search (1)
  • will (1)
see all

Quick Links

  • Home
  • Services
  • About Us
  • Blog
  • Contact Us

Contact Us

  •  800-709-1131
  •  40 West High Street
    Somerville, NJ 08876
  •  info@simonattorneys.com

Follow Us