The operating agreement is the LLC's internal constitution — and the most important document the business creates.

The calls follow patterns. The two founders who have been operating their software LLC on a handshake for three years, who are now in dispute over how much each contributed and what each is owed, and who never put an operating agreement in place. The family LLC formed five years ago for asset-protection purposes that has been holding the family's investment properties — and whose original "we'll do it later" deferred-drafting decision has now created uncertainty about who has authority to refinance the loans. The two equal owners whose 50/50 vote has deadlocked on whether to sell the business, with neither willing to back down. The widow whose late husband's LLC interest has passed to the estate, and who has just been told by the surviving partner that the operating agreement (which she's never read) requires her to sell her late husband's interest at book value. The new partner who has just agreed to buy 30% of an existing LLC and needs to know whether the operating agreement protects his 30% from being squeezed out by the 70% majority.

The operating agreement is the LLC's internal constitution. Done well, it anticipates the predictable conflicts and provides agreed mechanisms for resolving them. Done poorly or not at all, it leaves the members governed by RULLCA defaults that rarely match their actual deal — and creates the conditions for partnership disputes that the parties would have avoided entirely with proper documentation.

Why operating agreements matter — even for single-member LLCs.

Under N.J.S.A. 42:2C-12source, an LLC's affairs are governed by its operating agreement, with RULLCA defaults applying where the operating agreement is silent. The operating agreement covers:

• Relations among members.
• Rights and duties of members and managers.
• Activities of the LLC and conduct of those activities.
• Means and conditions for amending the operating agreement.

Most RULLCA defaults can be overridden by the operating agreement. A few cannot — including certain core fiduciary duties (which can be modified but not eliminated entirely), the access of members to information, and the powers of a court to dissolve a deadlocked LLC. The drafting work is in identifying what the members want, structuring it correctly, and ensuring it's enforceable under the applicable rules.

Even single-member LLCs need operating agreements:

• Veil-piercing protection. The operating agreement is evidence that the LLC is a separate entity from the member — one piece of the defense against alter-ego veil-piercing claims under Verni v. Harry M. Stevens, Inc.source.
• Management framework. Even single-member LLCs need a documented structure for how the LLC operates, what authority the member has, how decisions are documented.
• Succession planning. What happens to the LLC if the member dies, becomes incapacitated, or wants to transfer the interest?
• Bank, lender, contracting requirements. Banks ordinarily ask for an operating agreement before opening a business account in the LLC's name, and lenders generally request one as part of commercial-loan due diligence — so the document a single-member owner skips at formation is often the first thing a third party asks to see.

Capital contributions and capital accounts.

Capital provisions are where most early disputes are born or avoided. They record what each member actually put in, how that stake is tracked over time, and what happens when the business needs more money than it is generating. Getting them precise at formation — while everyone is still aligned — is far easier than reconstructing contributions from memory and bank records years later, after a disagreement has already started. The provisions specify what each member contributed and what their capital account looks like:

• Initial contributions — what each member contributed at formation (cash, property, services, with tax consequences coordinated with a CPA or tax counsel).
• Capital accounts — running tally of each member's economic stake, increased by contributions and allocated profit, decreased by distributions and allocated loss.
• Additional contributions — when and how members can or must contribute additional capital. Required additional contributions are unusual; voluntary additional contributions on a pro-rata basis are common.
• Capital calls — formal demand on members for additional capital. Failure to fund typically results in dilution, conversion of the unfunded amount to a member loan, or other consequences specified in the agreement.
• Loans vs. capital — distinguishing member loans from capital contributions, with tax treatment reviewed by tax professionals.

Allocations and distributions.

Allocation and distribution are the economic heart of the operating agreement, and the two are easy to conflate. Allocation decides whose tax return reports each dollar of profit or loss; distribution decides who actually receives cash. The two can diverge — a member can owe tax on allocated income in a year the LLC distributes nothing — which is exactly why tax-distribution and waterfall provisions exist. We draft the business-law mechanics and coordinate the tax treatment with a CPA or tax counsel:

• Allocation — tax-accounting treatment of LLC profit and loss, allocated to members under the operating agreement and coordinated with tax professionals. Allocation language may need to satisfy "substantial economic effect" under Treas. Reg. § 1.704-1(b)source.
• Distribution — actual cash (or property) payment from LLC to members.
• Pro-rata distribution — simplest structure; works for proportional members.
• Preferred returns — specified percentage on contributed capital paid first; common in LLCs with outside investors or unequal contribution.
• Waterfall structures — distributions in tiers (return of capital → preferred return → split of remaining); common in real-estate JVs and investment funds.
• Carried interest / promote — active members receive disproportionate share of upside as compensation for sweat equity.
• Targeted allocations — allocations designed to produce specific ending capital-account balances consistent with the desired distribution waterfall.
• Tax distributions — distributions designed to help members address tax liability on allocations, with mechanics reviewed by tax professionals.

Management — voting, authority, fiduciary duties.

Management provisions decide who can bind the LLC, what decisions need broad agreement, and what duties the members and managers owe each other. Because the RULLCA default gives every member one vote regardless of ownership — so a 90% owner and a 10% owner each carry the same weight — most multi-member agreements rework voting from the ground up. The provisions below are where that work happens:

• Member-managed vs. manager-managed. Default RULLCA structure is member-managed; manager-managed must be specified.
• Voting thresholds. Default is one-vote-per-member; operating agreement typically modifies to ownership-percentage voting. Majority threshold for ordinary matters; supermajority or unanimous consent for fundamental matters (admission of new members, amendment of operating agreement, sale of substantially all assets, dissolution).
• Officer roles — if manager-managed, the roles of CEO, President, CFO, Secretary, others.
• Decision categories — ordinary-course decisions (operations, hiring, ordinary contracting) vs. major decisions (large contracts, capital expenditures above threshold, debt above threshold, real estate transactions, related-party transactions) vs. fundamental decisions (admission of new members, amendment, dissolution).
• Fiduciary duties under N.J.S.A. 42:2C-39source — duty of loyalty, duty of care, obligation of good faith and fair dealing. Modifiable by operating agreement within statutory limits.
• Indemnification of members and managers for liability arising from LLC activities, with limitations for bad-faith or willful misconduct.
• Meeting and consent procedures — annual meetings, special meetings, written consents in lieu of meetings.

Transfer restrictions.

The point of transfer restrictions is control over who your partners are. Without them, the RULLCA default lets a member freely assign the economic interest to anyone — a competitor, an ex-spouse in a divorce, a bankruptcy trustee — and while that transferee does not gain management or voting rights, the remaining members can still find themselves entangled with a stranger's claim on the business. Multi-member LLCs commonly layer the following restrictions to keep that from happening:

• Right of First Refusal (ROFR) — selling member must first offer the interest to LLC/remaining members at the terms offered by a third party.
• Right of First Offer (ROFO) — variation; selling member must first offer to LLC/remaining members at a stated price.
• Tag-along rights — minority members can join in a majority-led sale on the same terms.
• Drag-along rights — majority (or specified supermajority) can compel minority to join in a sale on the same terms, facilitating clean 100% exit transactions.
• Substitute-member approval — purchaser of an interest receives only the economic interest unless members consent to admission. Default under RULLCA is unanimous; operating agreement often loosens.
• Prohibited transfers — to competitors, on bankruptcy, on divorce, to enumerated categories.
• Permitted transfers — to estate planning trusts, immediate family, controlled entities; typically without ROFR or consent.

Buy-sell provisions.

Among the most important parts of an operating agreement for multi-member LLCs. Triggering events typically include:

• Death of a member.
• Disability (long-term, typically 12+ months unable to perform substantial duties).
• Retirement (with notice).
• Voluntary withdrawal outside retirement (often with discounted valuation).
• Involuntary withdrawal for cause (theft, embezzlement, gross negligence, breach of fiduciary duty, criminal conviction).
• Divorce of a member (purchase to prevent non-member spouse from becoming a member).
• Bankruptcy of a member.
• Default on capital call.

Pricing methodology:

• Book value (capital account balance).
• Stipulated value (annually updated by member resolution).
• Formula valuation (EBITDA multiple, revenue percent, agreed metric).
• Independent appraisal (typically with marketability and lack-of-control discounts).
• Fair value as defined in NJ judicial-dissolution case law.
• Last-offered value (most recent third-party offer for the interest).

A buy-sell is only as good as the money behind it. A provision that obligates the LLC or the remaining members to purchase a departed member's interest is worth little if no one can fund the purchase when the trigger actually fires. Agreements ordinarily pair each triggering event with a funding source: term life insurance for death, disability insurance for long-term disability, promissory notes from the LLC for retirement and voluntary departures, and self-funding from operating reserves. Matching the funding to the trigger at drafting time is what keeps a buy-sell from becoming an unenforceable promise at the worst possible moment.

Deadlock resolution.

Essential in 50/50 LLCs and important in any multi-member LLC where minority blocking power creates risk. Options:

• Mediation first. Required attempt before any binding mechanism.
• Arbitration. Binding arbitration with designated arbitrator and rules.
• Designated tie-breaker. Neutral third party (outside board member, advisor) with binding authority on specified matters.
• Buy-sell triggers. Russian Roulette / Shotgun (one member offers a price; the other accepts the sale or compels the offering member to buy at that price); Texas Shoot-out (sealed bids; higher bidder wins); Dutch Auction (descending price).
• Forced sale. Deadlock triggers an orderly sale of the LLC's business with proceeds distributed under the waterfall.
• Judicial dissolution under N.J.S.A. 42:2C-48source as last resort.

Dissolution and winding up.

Every LLC ends eventually — by sale, by agreement, by a member's exit, or by court order — and the operating agreement decides whether that ending is orderly or contested. Well-drafted dissolution provisions tell the members in advance what triggers a wind-down, who controls the process, and how the last dollars are divided after creditors are paid. The agreement ordinarily addresses:

• Voluntary dissolution — by the member vote or threshold the agreement specifies.
• Mandatory dissolution — on specified events such as sale of substantially all assets, expiration of a fixed term, or the occurrence of a designated triggering event.
• Judicial dissolution — available on deadlock, oppression, or impossibility of carrying on the LLC's purpose under N.J.S.A. 42:2C-48source, with a court-appointed liquidator winding up the LLC's affairs.
• Winding-up procedures — liquidating activities, paying creditors, and distributing remaining assets in the order the distribution waterfall sets.

Tax-coordination provisions.

An operating agreement and a tax plan are not the same document, and treating them as one is a common and expensive mistake. We draft the business-law provisions that the tax structure rests on — who the partnership representative is, how tax distributions are calculated, how allocations are written so they hold up — and we coordinate with a CPA or tax counsel on the planning and return work, which is theirs to own. The provisions that ordinarily live in the agreement:

• Tax classification coordination. Default partnership taxation and alternative election questions should be reviewed with tax professionals.
• Partnership representative under the Bipartisan Budget Act of 2015 (BBA) — designated authority to act for the LLC in IRS partnership audits.
• NJ PTE BAIT election coordination under N.J.S.A. 54A:12-1 et seq.source — election analysis belongs with a CPA or tax counsel.
• Tax distribution provisions.
• Substantial economic effect under Treas. Reg. § 1.704-1(b)source — allocation language should be coordinated with tax professionals.

How engagement and fees work.

Operating-agreement work falls into a few predictable shapes, and we price it to match. A single-member operating agreement, or review of an existing agreement against the deal the members describe, is usually a defined-scope engagement. Drafting a multi-member agreement from scratch — capital, allocation and distribution, management, transfer restrictions, buy-sell, and deadlock all built around a specific deal — is more involved, and the scope depends on how many of those moving parts the members need and how far apart they start. Amendments to admit a new member or change economic terms, and disputes over how an existing buy-sell or valuation provision should be read, are scoped to the work in front of us. Where the agreement touches tax allocations, business valuation, or intellectual property, we coordinate with the CPA, tax counsel, valuation professional, or IP counsel who owns that piece rather than charging you to learn it. We explain the fee structure at the consultation, before any work begins.

Where to start.

The least expensive operating agreement is the one drafted before there is anything to argue about. Once a dispute has started — over who contributed what, over who has authority to act, over what a departing member's interest is worth — the same questions cost far more to answer, and the answer is often dictated by RULLCA defaults the members never chose. If you are forming a new LLC, taking on a partner, buying into an existing company, or holding an agreement you have never actually read, the consultation is where we map your situation against the statute and tell you plainly what the document does and does not protect. Tell us a little about the LLC and the people in it using the form below, and our intake team will follow up to schedule that conversation.

Frequently asked questions

Consult

Request a Case Evaluation

Answer a few questions and choose how you want the firm to follow up. Your request goes straight to our intake team for prompt, personal review.

Consultation request. There is no charge to send this form or to talk through your situation.

First Name *

Last Name *

Phone *

Email *

Address

Use your mailing address. It helps intake route the request and prepare conflict review.

Street Address *

Apartment, Suite, or Unit

City *

State *

ZIP Code *

What civil or business issue do you need help with? *

Include county, deadline, and names of other parties so the firm can review your matter.

Preferred follow-up * Phone call Text me Email

I agree to receive text messages from Simon Law Group about my request. Consent is optional, and message frequency may vary. Reply STOP to opt out. See the SMS terms. I understand that submitting this form is governed by the Terms of Service and Legal Disclaimer, does not create an attorney-client relationship, and should not include confidential documents before the firm confirms it can discuss my matter.

Website (leave blank)

Submit Case Evaluation

Sending this form does not create an attorney-client relationship. Please do not include confidential documents here.